Pause the Sheffield Plan.

Protect Sheffield's Green Belt for people and nature.

If the Sheffield Local Plan continues as it is, there will be cost to nature and communities.

The Sheffield Plan is now in the final stages of examination by the Governments Planning Inspectors. Our concerns echo those of thousands of people across Sheffield in that important places for people and valuable habitats for wildlife are threatened by the proposed green belt release and plans as they stand. 

Take action: make your voice heard

Tell your local councillor why they should support a pause on the Sheffield Plan before it is finalised.

To make it easy to contact your Sheffield City Council councillors, we have drafted an email for you to send.  On the form add your own words as to the issues that matter most and what the Green Belt means to you. You will be able to read and edit the email on the next page before you send it. Unfortunately, only residents in the Sheffield City Council area are able to take part in this action.

For more information on our concerns - see below.

Why Green Belt Matters

Green belt is more than grass fields. It prevents urban areas from merging into one another and provides valuable space for wildlife and local communities. They support biodiversity and people’s health and wellbeing.  

Many of the proposed Green Belt release sites are adjacent to important wildlife habitats, including ancient woodland, local wildlife sites, rivers and hedgerows. These areas provide shelter, safety, food and a route for wildlife to move across the landscape.  

The Sheffield Plan relies on the minimum recommended protections (buffers) between development and sensitive habitats. It has not been shown that these buffers will prevent damage. Other councils have adopted or proposed much stronger protections, recognising that wildlife needs more than the minimum space to survive or thrive.  

When it comes to counting how many homes a site can accommodate, the council do not appear to have taken even the proposed minimum buffers into consideration when calculating capacities. There is fear that unless better protections are agreed now at the local plan stage, the space to provide more adequate buffers will be taken so that capacity targets can be reached.

We want the Sheffield Plan to recognise these risks and guarantee that our most sensitive habitats will be protected where development is necessary, by writing stronger protections into policy rather than leaving these to be negotiated at the planning application stage.

Ancient Woodland

Ancient Woodland is an irreplaceable habitat, developed over centuries and therefore cannot be replaced if removed or damaged for development. 

However, at some sites, the Plan proposes complete isolation of areas of Ancient Woodland from other habitats which will impact its ability to function as a healthy ecosystem and prevent movement of wildlife. 

The impacts of the scale and types of development adjacent to Ancient Woodland have not been adequately considered. 

The Plan affords only the minimum 15 metre buffers intended to protect tree roots from direct damage. This distance does not consider the increased footfall, polluted runoff, air pollution, noise and artificial lighting. 

Natural England’s guidance is clear, the minimum recommended buffer is a starting point and that much larger buffers are likely to be needed depending on the scale of development and land use proposed to be developed. For example, proposed warehousing will be subject to a high level of HGV traffic and the adjacent Ancient Woodland ecosystem is highly susceptible to the predictable pollution from such use.

Other councils have gone considerably further in protecting ancient woodland, Wiltshire’s adopted Core Strategy required a 100 metre buffer and numerous others proposing 50 metres.

We want the Sheffield Plan to establish stronger minimum natural buffers based on the type of development proposed,  A minimum of 50 metres for housing and 50 - 100 metres for employment land, depending on the type (i.e intensive HGV use presents higher risk).

Hedgerows: More than Meets the Eye

Hedgerows are more than just green boundaries between fields; they provide vital habitat, corridors across the landscape to link other habitats.  They are an important part of our landscape and our natural, agricultural and cultural heritage.

Some hedgerows have existed for hundreds of years, marking historic field boundaries, administrative boundaries or ancient routes and as such may also qualify as irreplaceable habitats.  Their importance cannot be judged solely on just their species composition.  The Sheffield Plan provides strong protection for species-rich hedgerows but allows other hedgerows to be retained only ‘where possible’, without requiring an integrated assessment to identify whether they are ancient, irreplaceable or their importance for wildlife movement. 

Britain has already lost around half of its hedgerows since WW2, meaning those that remain are particularly valuable.  Heritage reports have identified hundreds of metres of potentially medieval field boundaries within proposed Sheffield Plan Green Belt allocations, yet development of these sites for housing or employment land could require removal of these hedgerows.

National planning policy recognises the historic, landscape and ecological value of established hedgerows, but the Sheffield Plan relies too heavily on ecological surveys.  These identify species and habitat condition but not whether they follow a centuries-old boundary or form part of the historic landscape.

Even when they are retained, development too close can damage their roots, restrict their growth or reduce their value as a wildlife corridor. 


We want the Sheffield Plan to require integrated ecological, heritage and landscape assessments to identify ancient or irreplaceable hedgerows, regardless of whether they are species rich, and to guarantee adequate protections through policy. 

We recommend a minimum 50 metre buffer around ancient or irreplaceable hedgerows.  This protection then needs to be taken into account when determining the development capacity of proposed sites.

Rivers and Watercourses

Rivers, streams and smaller watercourses are vital habitats, supporting fish, birds, mammals and insects.  They provide important wildlife corridors, connecting habitats across the landscape and allowing species to move.

Land alongside a watercourse (riparian zone) is just as important as the river or stream.  Trees, shrubs and other vegetation provide shade, shelter and food for wildlife, stabilise the riverbanks and act as natural flood defences.

The Sheffield Plan relies on narrow minimum buffers from the watercourses of 8 metres for a main river and only 3 metres for others, which do not necessarily protect the wider riparian zone.  Trees, shrubs and other vegetation can extend well beyond the top of the riverbank, yet these important habitats may be lost or damaged by development. 

Neither does the Plan adequately consider the cumulative impacts of polluted runoff, artificial lighting, increased disturbance and the reduced function as a wildlife corridor.

We want the Sheffield Plan to include stronger minimum buffers that protect the whole riparian zone rather than measuring a narrow distance from the top of the bank.  Again, these should be written into policy rather than being left to negotiations at the planning application stage.

 

Impacts on People and Nature

The impacts of these proposals are broader than impacts on habitats and wildlife. Development is  concentrated in certain areas in the city, many of which are home to communities that are already deprived of access to good quality natural greenspace. This inequality could become more severe once the sites are developed, particularly if their remaining habitats are not adequately protected. 

Further, protections need to be implemented that not only adequately protect the individual habitat, but also the wider ecological network. Therefore, this is not just an issue local to the proposed sites, but could impact ecological connectivity and biodiversity across the city.

 

Is the Sheffield Plan a Brownfield First Plan?

The Plan is advertised as being a brownfield first Plan, but our concern is that once these green belt sites are released there is no mechanism in place to ensure they are developed only after all suitable brownfield is exhausted.   

Sheffield’s Brownfield Land Register has not been updated since December 2023, despite a requirement to review and update it at least annually, raising concerns about whether all available urban sites have been truly considered.

The Council’s housing forecasts also assume that no homes will be delivered on larger previously unidentified sites during the first five years of the Plan.  Yet the delays have proven that significant numbers of homes have already been developed on sites not already included in the Plan, showing that the Council’s assumptions were inaccurate.  If these continue to come forward, it could reduce the number of homes needed on Green Belt Land.

We want the council to update its assessment of brownfield opportunities, review its housing forecasts and add a mechanism to ensure that Green Belt Land only comes forward after brownfield has genuinely been exhausted.

 

Sound doesn't mean good

The Planning Inspectors will soon determine whether the Sheffield Plan meets the legal requirements and tests of soundness. But passing those tests does not necessarily make it a good plan.

It is our elected Council that must ultimately decide whether this is the right Plan for Sheffield, whether it is fair to our communities and whether it provides the protection our natural environment deserves.

We believe there is still time to get this right, so we are asking councillors to support a short pause before the examination concludes to make it better.

Contact your local councillor and and ensure they understand why they should ask for a pause.